(Kos Samara’s post from the FACEBOOK on 14 May2026.)
(Opposition
Leader) Angus Taylor’s Budget in reply. Why has he just turned the blow
torch on Chinese Australians? “You cannot access certain government services (such
as Age Pension, Dole, and Carer Allowances, etc.) if you are not an Australian
citizen, even if you are granted permanent residency.”
The
core issue is simple: China does not recognise dual nationality. Under Article
3 of China’s Nationality Law, China does not recognise dual nationality for any
Chinese national. Article 9 goes further, any Chinese national who has settled
abroad and voluntarily acquires foreign nationality automatically loses their
Chinese nationality.
No other major country Australia takes migrants from has this strict a rule. So for a China-born Chinese Australian, taking Australian citizenship is not an administrative step. It is, in legal terms, a severing.
It
can mean losing or seriously complicating access to:
–
Property, inheritance, bank accounts, pensions, and business interests in
China,
–
Family obligations under the hukou household registration system, which governs
identity, services and local entitlements
For
many it is also emotional. Citizenship is tied to parents, birthplace, ancestry
and family duty. Becoming an Australian on paper can feel like, or be seen by
relatives as, a formal cutting of the cord. It was for many post WW2 migrants
too.
Australian
permanent residency already gives the right to live, work, study, own property,
use Medicare and build a life here. The marginal benefit of citizenship is
small. The cost of losing Chinese nationality is not.
That is why a large number of Chinese-Australian households deliberately keep at least one family member as a Chinese citizen. It is risk management, keeping the family’s legal foothold in China intact. It is not disloyalty.
Compare
this to every other migrant community in Australia. Lebanese, Iraqi, Turkish,
Pakistani, Bangladeshi, Indian, European, African, Latin American, Pacific,
overwhelmingly, the countries they came from permit dual citizenship. Muslim
Australians from those source countries can naturalise without losing anything.
So can virtually every other group.
China
is the outlier. So Chinese Australians are the ones who pay the cost and who he
seems to be targeting. The political consequence is significant. A suburb can
have a large, settled, economically integrated Chinese-Australian population,
and a voting-age citizen footprint that is materially smaller than the raw
demographic count suggests. Permanent residents cannot enrol to vote. They are
deeply embedded in Australia, but absent from the electoral roll.
Now overlay Angus Taylor’s values-based migration agenda, citizenship as the test of belonging, the Australian Values Statement as a binding visa condition, naturalisation as the proof of loyalty. That framework falls hardest on the one major migrant community where taking Australian citizenship means losing legal ties to your parents’ country. Every other community can naturalise freely. Chinese Australians cannot, not without real legal and family cost.
When
Taylor escalates the citizenship-as-loyalty framework, the group it
disproportionately punishes is obvious. This is what an anti-China policy looks
like in practice, even when it is not named as one. Clearly, he has decided
that they no longer have a future in Sydney or Melbourne.
Cry me a river: Take it up with Xi Jinping.
Angus
Taylor is bang on correct. Non-citizens should not have the right to the
Australian welfare system. If you’re moving to Australia from another country
to permanently live here then you need to put Australia first if you want all
of the benefits that go with being Australian.
If
your country of origin does not allow you to be a dual citizen, then take that
up with the other country. But do your want to remain where you were? Or do you
want to become Australian?
And
for the record, Australia for a long time wouldn’t allow emigrants from
Australia to other countries to adopt their new nation’s citizenship without
losing their Australian citizenship in the process. I’m not sure when that was
changed, but I think it was sometime after 2000. I know this because I was born
in New Zealand to an Australian mother. That is how I am born an immigrant and
a 4th or 5th generation Australian.
All
I can say is that if you truly want to be Australian then you have got to be
prepared to leave the country you came from behind. And with that I’ll add: GO
WALLABIES! I will be cheering for the Wallabies to defeat the All Blacks in the
next Bledisloe Cup.
Advance
Australia Fair!




